I got the same crap from Verizon, they collect the money and charge me extra but they have no control over cancelling the service. Verizon is in on the scam if you ask me. I agree that we should all send $9.99 less to Verizon for charges we did not incur.
I got a message on Saturday saying that I am renewed although I didn't order anything. Tried calling 800 # and got message that it was no longer in use. Sent an email to them to stop and also filled out their cancel form. I am going to Sprint to make sure this is not on my phone.