Did they mail you proof of this debt before you started paying them? Because phone calls are not legal methods of debt validation. Nor are emails, texts, or faxes.
You might want to speak to your bank about stopping payment on the check you sent them if they haven't cashed it yet. There's something fishy about a company that demands payment but hasn't processed that payment in two months.
They are from simonsagency, an illegal debt collecting agency that doesn't obey Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. Has called me on a recycled T-Mobile number 5 times the past 2 days despite me asking them to remove me because they're looking for the wrong person - they told me "they can't remove me because only <name of person they are trying to collect debt from> can" and then hung up.
They keep calling my husband looking for me so I answered and they didnt even have a reason for calling. So confusing. They were rude and hung up on me and began calling 3 times a day since.