Received a call, asking for the man of the house by name. This call follows screaming into the ears of a caller from 414-354-9561 (who calls asking for money for various "charities"). Not thoroughly convinced this is a scam number or anything. And an address search brings up the homeowner as "J. Betz" so Jim seems to be a fitting name.
Worth noting: The address a reverse lookup shows is 2330 N Prospect, but when you Google that address, it's actually a retirement home (Milwaukee Catholic Home), and all of the numbers in that area begin with 224, not 273. This is a dubious number given this information.