Caller identified himself as from "police conference of New York". They have a website and look legit. However, check out their charity form filed with the New York State Attorney General:
https://www.charitiesnys.com/RegistrySearch/s ... 89209E16C31E%7d
If you download the 2015 form, you will see that their annual fundraising is $1.25 million while they paid $1.01 million for professional fundraising fees. Much of the rest goes to salaries. Clearly, not very much of what you give is going to police officers. Like everyone else cold calling you these days, this outfit is a scam.