Nothing will come of it as long as you don't pay them extortion money. You people need to do 2 things. First, report this to the real police, and second, stay off of that site (POF)
Under Age Girl Scam
Yes it is an extortion scam being run on or by that site. There are numerous number threads her with the same story.
Guy called me trying to blackmail me saying his 16 year old daughter has naked pictures of me and they want me to pay for the replacement of their phone and the cost of a plane ticket back to Pittsburgh.